The polygamist pauses, his hand hovered above the doorknob. He looks back down the hallway, blinking in the harsh light of the naked bulb he has just flipped on to do war with the shapeless darkness of the night. A few paces away - no further away than a firm decision - stands another door: silent, inviting. His gaze returns to the door in front of him; also as silent as the entrance to Aladdin's cave. Which door should he open? Which of his beloved wives should he visit?
Okay, I admit it, I know nothing about polygamy. I once caught an episode of Big Love on telly, and I enjoyed reading Lola Shoneyin's The Secret Lives Of Baba Segi's Wives, but that's about it.
I do, however, know a bit about Oracle Forms and Oracle Application Express. Which is kinda fortunate since I'm guessing you're not here for marital advice. A question I do get asked from time to time - most recently on LinkedIn - is this: What technology should I choose for my new project - Oracle Forms or Oracle Application Express?
At the risk of sounding like a guru sat atop a Himalayan rock, there is only one real answer to this question: look within your heart, the answer floats like an asteroid in the galaxy of your inner space. Or something. Personally, if I was making the decision a year ago I'd have said Apex cos it was new and exciting; today, I'd probably say Forms, cos it's old and I better understand its foibles: the polygamist's dilemma - the new, nubile wife, or the old wife who he fully understands?
You will probably want to base your decision on factors more concrete and quantifiable than imaginary asteroids, so here are some things to consider.
Skills: What skills do you have? What skills are you willing to invest in? What skills are you capable of acquiring? I would imagine that you have a greater wealth of Forms experience. This need not be the deciding factor, but it should definitely count as a tick in that box. I was able to retrain my team of Forms developers in Apex, but it took some time and some expense. And, crucially, it was a challenge they were happy to face: I still have nightmares about The Big Oracle ADF Disaster of 2008. My therapist says I'll get over it one day, but I doubt it.
Platform: A huge part of your choice must depend on the demands of the project itself. For instance, what platform are you hoping to run it on? If you are planning to take advantage of the current boom in mobile computing, then Apex should be your choice. I must admit that I have not yet tried to run a Forms application on a phone or a tablet, but I do not suspect that that is an experiment that would end happily.
Cost: If you are a millionaire Saudi Arabian prince who has only got to this page cos you googled "I am looking for the oracle on polygamy", you can skip this bit. The rest of you, pay attention. With its middleware costs, Forms is undeniably the more expensive option. I am not allowed anywhere near the money at my company, but I am assured that the difference in cost can be considerable.
Audience: Who is your application aimed at? If it is to be published on the open Internet, then you only really have one choice - Apex. I am not denying the work Oracle's Forms team has done to modernise the old girl, but I doubt that it will ever be truly suitable for the world-wide web.
Speed: I cannot get my hands on the exact figures now, but I have read that for every tenth of a second that Amazon manages to shave off their website's response time, sales increase by many millions of dollars. Google experienced a similar increase in the stickiness of their site when they introduced Google Instant. If response times are as crucial to your project, then perhaps you should be leaning towards lightweight Apex. But do not dismiss Forms out of hand; from 11g, it is possible to slash load times by pre-starting runtime engines. The tortoise may have bought itself some roller skates.
Deployability: Our IT team are forever engaged in a battle with Oracle Application Server. One of them - OAS or the IT guys - isn't very good at their job. Since no one at Oracle has ever bought me a drink at the pub, I'll assume it's their fault. Apex is easier to deploy than Forms; indeed there is a growing number of companies that will host your Apex application for you.
The Big Picture: You have to consider the wider context. In my case, the option of building Forms applications is a receding one, since my company has taken the decision to move towards Apex. We now have a cohort of new, young developers to who Forms is Betamax.
Conclusion: The polygamist makes his decision and quietly opens a door. He enters the room and closes the door behind him. Are you awake? he whispers into the darkness. There is a crack in the curtains, and a shaft of milky moonlight is lying across the bed like an abandoned sword. Yes, a voice whispers from beneath the covers. He walks towards the sound, his pace quickens with excitement.
There is no universally right or wrong answer; it depends on your project and the factors I have named above (and the many I have not thought of - which is why there is a comments section below).
PS: I'd like to thank Steve Cairns for his help with this post. He is one of the country's leading experts on polygamy. Or Oracle technologies. I forget which.